wreckedmyteg

For background see here: https://honda-tech.com/zerothread?id=973256

I recently had my second 51R yellow top fail (a very common problem).

I called Optima after they didn't respond to my emails. As soon as I mention 51R, this is what she told me:

If your battery is in the 2 year warranty period, and you have your original receipt, they will refund the base price of the battery (total cost excluding sales tax).

If your in the 2 year warranty period, but do not have a receipt (they can verify whether or not you bought it in the last two years by the code on the side of the battery), they will send you a replacement Optima, but it will be on of the larger ones (they've discontinued the 51R due to all the problems it's had).

So go get your money back!

I'm buying one of these instead (nearly identical specs):



SPV35, Designed for the Honda / Acura battery size. $110 bucks. I'm getting $134 back from Optima for their POS paper weight.

Solscud007

where can you get that other battery?

wreckedmyteg

Any Stinger authorized dealer. I've seen them on eBay as well.

.brian.

damn, i had an optima red top in my old car (a regualr sized optima) and never had a problem with it.

good looking out, though

nitrofish420

I had a 51R yellow top go bad on me in my CRX, but I bought it off Ebay, so I figured I was screwed on any warrantee...

jdm'dc2sc61

mine just died out recently as well, and its only been less that a yr. i purchased it off ebay too, but im gonna call and see if they'll send me a new one. even tho its the bigger one, ill just resell it or something. i almost bought a new d51r, good thing i came across this post, thx~

jonshonda

Nothing but good things from the Stinger

CubanLynx84

I have the yellow top bu tthe bigger oine and I haven't had any problems and I have had it now for like 5 years. What's the problem with those 51r's cause I do have one of those too but never used it. My friend gave it to me cause he took it out of his civic when he sold it. He didn't have any problems with it either.

wreckedmyteg

All the 51R's seem to have the same problem. The metal straps that connect all the cells lift away or break, causing one or more dead cells.

Micha

I have never had a problem and I have had my 51R for over 2 years. I don't know? Maybe I was lucky.

nsxtasy

I just bought a new battery for my Integra at Costco after shopping around. Comes with a 100 month warranty. Kirkland brand (that's their house brand) made by Johnson Controls, a major battery manufacturer. Only $37.

wreckedmyteg

<TABLE WIDTH="90%" CELLSPACING=0 CELLPADDING=0 ALIGN=CENTER><TR><TD>Quote, originally posted by nsxtasy &raquo;</TD></TR><TR><TD CLASS="quote">I just bought a new battery for my Integra at Costco after shopping around. Comes with a 100 month warranty. Kirkland brand (that's their house brand) made by Johnson Controls, a major battery manufacturer. Only $37.
</TD></TR></TABLE>

Good deal, but I'm looking for another AGM style battery. Also, Optima is a subsidiary of JCI as well.

SexiMexi

i have a 51r. im fucked.


if it ends up going out then ill probably just get the big one and relocate it.

cm zak

I got a yellow top but i havent had it fail, and i dont think its that model....

wreckedmyteg

<TABLE WIDTH="90%" CELLSPACING=0 CELLPADDING=0 ALIGN=CENTER><TR><TD>Quote, originally posted by cm zak &raquo;</TD></TR><TR><TD CLASS="quote">I got a yellow top but i haven't had it fail, and i dont think its that model....</TD></TR></TABLE>

The title reads "ATTN Optima 51R Yellow top owners!". If you don't have a 51R this doesn't apply to you.

Sack Master

I've had my 51r for about a year and a half and it's been fine. I guess time will tell. I know the regular yellow tops are great and very few people have problems with them. That's why I bought mine.

madredintegra

I have the same stinger battery that you have pictured and I haven't had ANY problems w/ it. I've had it for about 2 1/2 years now w/ no trouble.

wreckedmyteg

Got my new battery installed.

It's an Interstate AGM. It's got a 50 AH reserve, vs the Optima's 41.

It's also more CCA, and weighs a good 10-15 pounds more as well. Never realized how inefficient the spiral-cell packaging design is.

This one is just a little fatter then the optima, but it still fit in the factory tray with a little elbow grease.

This battery is primarily used in motorized wheel chairs, but hey, it works! Maybe now I can park in handi-cap stalls. w00t!







Not bad pics for a camera phone...Sanyo MM-9000 rocks!