Print  Email  Subscribe  RSS  Help
 B20 blocks, Whats you experience? [Archived]First  1 2 >  Last
Author Post

mx621




Offline

904 posts [100%]
little place called HELL
9-10-2005
  B20 blocks, Whats you experience?« » Reply  Edit


Well the search is still down .. so i am here.

At my first HPDE last weekend i had a little engine trouble in my last session. lets just say we found the #3 rod and the other pieces on the track. from the looks of things i believe the ARP rod bolt broke causing the failure. luckily the head is all ok. bottom end was stock ls rods w/ arp bolts. motor (see sig) ran flawlessly all day until the very end of my last session when it let go.

on the the topic:
I have had a B20 block for some time now and i have been wanting to use it. My main question is what has been your experience with b20's at track conditions, 6-8500 rpms for a full session/race. i have herd mixed reviews some say they work great, blah blah blah, some not so great it will crack a sleeve in a matter of time. i know B20 blocks hold up fine on street/strip cars, but track time is a hole new ballpark.

I am thinking about a gsr crank/rods in the b20 block, kind of a power meets reliability build. i know Omniman did this setup (b20/gsr crank/rods) a few years ago with good results.

I am just looking for some input from those who may have B20 experience and how it held up.

thanks!



I pray cancer on theives, and the mothers that gave birth to them...

ls/v, p30's, pro2's = 225/154 jeff evans tuned
12.907 @ 105.8 w/ best trap of 108.8mph in a 2550lb w/ driver DC2
http://www.EVANS-TUNING.com






Lo-Buck EF




Offline

4571 posts [101%]
NY
10-6-2001
 « Re: B20 blocks, Whats you experience? (mx621)« » Reply  Edit


kevin from hondaworks loves him some ls-vtec and b20 vtec in his H1 car.
itll stay together and work great if you build it right.



ECHC# 516 H2

Stinkycheezmonky
Instructwhore



Offline

8177 posts [101%]
Burninating the peasants
11-5-2002
 « Re: B20 blocks, Whats you experience? (Lo-Buck EF)« » Reply  Edit


I've been tracking a relatively stock B20 motor for the past 2-3 years with great success. My bottom end is all stock right down to the pistons and it's plenty fast for an HPDE-type event. I might get down the straights slower than a B20-VTEC car but I have an easier time putting the power down in corners. I refreshed the motor last year (bearings and rings) and it's still running very strong. I plan on sticking with this for a long time. Replacements are dirt cheap too, so if I blow it up I'm not that sad.

Only things to keep in mind with non-VTEC B-series engines are oil heat and oil starvation. Problems easily solved with an oil cooler and baffled oil pan respectively. The cooler isn't necessary even, but the pan is (IMO) essential.



Paradise on my left, Hell on my right, and the Angel of Death behind.

Shifter Kart Mafia Member 005


mx621




Offline

904 posts [100%]
little place called HELL
9-10-2005
 « Re: B20 blocks, Whats you experience? (Stinkycheezmonky)« » Reply  Edit


wow!! that was fast..

thanks for the replies, it will be a B20/v setup. i am hoping using the gsr crank/rod setup will ease the stress a little at high rpms on the track. i know its not even 2mm less stroke, but ill take it.

I would hate to put together this motor and after a few events (hpde's) bust a sleeve .., lol.



I pray cancer on theives, and the mothers that gave birth to them...

ls/v, p30's, pro2's = 225/154 jeff evans tuned
12.907 @ 105.8 w/ best trap of 108.8mph in a 2550lb w/ driver DC2
http://www.EVANS-TUNING.com




Stinkycheezmonky
Instructwhore



Offline

8177 posts [101%]
Burninating the peasants
11-5-2002
 « Re: B20 blocks, Whats you experience? (mx621)« » Reply  Edit


High rpm + high compression are what kill the cylinder walls. Keep those reasonable and you'll be fine. A good tune will also be necessary of course.



Paradise on my left, Hell on my right, and the Angel of Death behind.

Shifter Kart Mafia Member 005


mx621




Offline

904 posts [100%]
little place called HELL
9-10-2005
 « Re: B20 blocks, Whats you experience? (Stinkycheezmonky)« » Reply  Edit


what would you consider reasonable rpms?



I pray cancer on theives, and the mothers that gave birth to them...

ls/v, p30's, pro2's = 225/154 jeff evans tuned
12.907 @ 105.8 w/ best trap of 108.8mph in a 2550lb w/ driver DC2
http://www.EVANS-TUNING.com




Stinkycheezmonky
Instructwhore



Offline

8177 posts [101%]
Burninating the peasants
11-5-2002
 « Re: B20 blocks, Whats you experience? (mx621)« » Reply  Edit


Not more than 8500, but I'm no guru. Look through the LS/V thread here, lots of good info and experience: http://www.honda-tech.com/zerothread?id=1676914



Paradise on my left, Hell on my right, and the Angel of Death behind.

Shifter Kart Mafia Member 005


B18CXr




Offline

6580 posts [101%]
NC
10-27-2000
 « « » Reply  Edit


If you rev a B20 over 7800-8000 on track, it will fail sooner/later.

Kevin gets around two weekends outta his @ 9,000ish rev limit.


Trust me.

Do the piston speed math and you'll see. (i.e. keep it under 7900 if you want it to last)



Stinkycheezmonky
Instructwhore



Offline

8177 posts [101%]
Burninating the peasants
11-5-2002
 « Re: (B18CXr)« » Reply  Edit


Quote, originally posted by B18CXr »
Trust me.

Take his advice



Paradise on my left, Hell on my right, and the Angel of Death behind.

Shifter Kart Mafia Member 005


vtecjj




Offline

722 posts [98%]
Sacramento Ca
10-6-2001
 « Re: B20 blocks, Whats you experience? (mx621)« » Reply  Edit


I've been running the B20/vtec combo since the '06 Honda Challenge Nationals.

In in '06, I ran the Type R rods and crank & 85mm pistons with NO BLOCK GUARD and cracked the cylinders in 1 1/2 days at Mid Ohio. I had one of the most powerful engines running at Mid-Ohio in '06 before the cylinder crackage. Just before we went to nationals the engine was dyno'ing at 242whp @8900rpms. When the engine started to fail, I was only revving it to 8500rpms on the track.

At the '07 Nationals, Helms and I (both with B20's) had 222whp and 221 whp, respectively (dyno at Nationals). This time I kept the engine under 8800rpms all weekend, ran the LS crank & rods with a blockguard and the engine lasted without any problems and no compression lost at all.
Typically with the block guard, revving to 8500-8800rpms hasn't been a problem.

I have a BRAND NEW B20 shortblock (my backup engine & identical to last year's nationals engine) that hasn't been started/ran yet for sale if you're interested



GI8U2racing




Offline

410 posts [100%]
Bowie, MD / Bangalore, India
9-10-2006
 « Re: B20 blocks, Whats you experience? (vtecjj)« » Reply  Edit


Again referencing Kevin Helmes...

Before I picked what class/engine I wanted to do for HC, we spoke a lot about the B-series, especially the B20. His main mechanic was there as well, I don't remember his name, but he was quite helpful too, here was the verdict:

For high HP engines, like over 210 whp, the thing is going to be marginal on reliability, in that the sleeve will crack. He was getting 2-4 weekends out of a motor. One time last year, he even ran a B18C5 without telling anyone, at the B-series weight (don't know if this was a secret or not) just to do it, and still won the EC H1 HC event. He also mentioned not revving it as high as say a B16 or B18, as that instigates the sleeve cracking sooner.

However, he loves the damn B20, and can afford to toss a block every 2-4 weekends, he owns HondaWorks.

I'd say if you are set on the B20, do it, but don't build it over 210 whp, and watch your rev's...



Jonathan Baker

1988 CRX HF w/B18C5 - HPDE (soon H2) car
Check my profile for the setup


thawley




Offline

1234 posts [100%]
Orange County
3-23-2004
 « Re: B20 blocks, Whats you experience? (GI8U2racing)« » Reply  Edit


This is why I'm such a fan of the stock head on the B20 in H2...

That head will never breathe well enough to approach the failure point on the sleeves. If you keep the RPM & piston speed down, every thing is happy and lasts. As soon as you rev it hard you start living on borrowed time.





E. John Thawley III

mx621




Offline

904 posts [100%]
little place called HELL
9-10-2005
 « Re: B20 blocks, Whats you experience? (thawley)« » Reply  Edit


thanks alot guys for the input .. i think i am going to rebuild the same ls/v i currently have using forged rods rather than the stockers with arp bolts.



I pray cancer on theives, and the mothers that gave birth to them...

ls/v, p30's, pro2's = 225/154 jeff evans tuned
12.907 @ 105.8 w/ best trap of 108.8mph in a 2550lb w/ driver DC2
http://www.EVANS-TUNING.com




spock_rocker
memoryFAB.com representative



Offline

7819 posts [100%]
MEMORYFAB.COM
7-24-2002
 « Re: B20 blocks, Whats you experience? (Stinkycheezmonky)« » Reply  Edit


Quote, originally posted by Stinkycheezmonky »
I've been tracking a relatively stock B20 motor for the past 2-3 years with great success. My bottom end is all stock right down to the pistons and it's plenty fast for an HPDE-type event..

same here, but i have the B20Z.. not really much difference but ive had a great time with it and such



AIM = Hangoroshi Omoi
http://www.MemoryFab.com PM me if anything
circuit///hero
::TeamSloth:htolSmeaT::


sander
tunARrr



Offline

1662 posts [100%]
Maryland
2-14-2003
 « Re: B20 blocks, Whats you experience? (thawley)« » Reply  Edit


Quote, originally posted by thawley »
This is why I'm such a fan of the stock head on the B20 in H2...

That head will never breathe well enough to approach the failure point on the sleeves. If you keep the RPM & piston speed down, every thing is happy and lasts. As soon as you rev it hard you start living on borrowed time.

This is not totally true. The P8R cylinder head is a much better candidate for head flow and with the appropriate sized cams they can absolutely make power in the 8-8500 range.


jdm-ek-si




Offline

135 posts [100%]
Atlanta GA
2-19-2007
 « « » Reply  Edit


i have been running a b20 with b16 trans for a while in hpde's and never had a problem
but it is the same with every thing on a car the harder u beat it (no homo) the faster it breaks



please stop in and see my build
http://www.honda-tech.com/zerothread/2278523

90_EX_Civic




Offline

683 posts [94%]
PA
1-25-2008
 « Re: (jdm-ek-si)« » Reply  Edit


i was going to suggest using the b20 block, but instead of a block guard, post the block. you'll have about the same safety as a block guard but you won't restrict the stock cooling effect.



PS3 gamer tag: hmmhuh (call me 2B)

I HATE GRENADES!


vtecjj




Offline

722 posts [98%]
Sacramento Ca
10-6-2001
 « Re: (90_EX_Civic)« » Reply  Edit


Quote, originally posted by 90_EX_Civic »
i was going to suggest using the b20 block, but instead of a block guard, post the block. you'll have about the same safety as a block guard but you won't restrict the stock cooling effect.

I haven't had any cooling issues with a block guard at all, and I've raced 50min on a road course revving to 8500+rpms with one. There's more restriction issues with the head gasket than the block guard. (the passages in the head gasket restrict more flow than a block guard does).


90_EX_Civic




Offline

683 posts [94%]
PA
1-25-2008
 « Re: (vtecjj)« » Reply  Edit


Quote, originally posted by vtecjj »

There's more restriction issues with the head gasket than the block guard. (the passages in the head gasket restrict more flow than a block guard does).


yeah, but wouldn't the restriction from both add up??? you got the head gasket that is restrictive, then you add a block guard that'll add more restriction to it. doesn't that add up?



PS3 gamer tag: hmmhuh (call me 2B)

I HATE GRENADES!


vtecjj




Offline

722 posts [98%]
Sacramento Ca
10-6-2001
 « Re: (90_EX_Civic)« » Reply  Edit


Quote, originally posted by 90_EX_Civic »

yeah, but wouldn't the restriction from both add up??? you got the head gasket that is restrictive, then you add a block guard that'll add more restriction to it. doesn't that add up?

I see what you're saying, but my guess is that the amount of water going to and through head gasket is the same with or without my block guard installed. I don't know which block guard you're talking about causing cooling issues, but I use the Golden Eagle block guard and it has adequately wide water passages-without sacraficing cylinder support. I've run the B20 with and WITHOUT the block guard and haven't seen any differences in water temps at all on the track.


thawley




Offline

1234 posts [100%]
Orange County
3-23-2004
 « Re: B20 blocks, Whats you experience? (sander)« » Reply  Edit


Quote, originally posted by sander »
The P8R cylinder head is a much better candidate for head flow and with the appropriate sized cams they can absolutely make power in the 8-8500 range.

I've heard all kinds of great things online about that head, but I've never seen back to back flow or dyno numbers. From what I've read it just has slightly larger intake valves and the same exhaust. If you've actually dynoed one that made good power up to 8500rpm I'd like to see the graph. Even with Crower 404s, I'd guess peak power is closer to 7500-7800. But that's just a guess (from someone who's run similar cams on a stock head...)

Please point me to any non-ported P8R dyno info you've seen. I'd be very interested.



E. John Thawley III

thawley




Offline

1234 posts [100%]
Orange County
3-23-2004
 « Re: (90_EX_Civic)« » Reply  Edit


Quote, originally posted by 90_EX_Civic »

yeah, but wouldn't the restriction from both add up??? you got the head gasket that is restrictive, then you add a block guard that'll add more restriction to it. doesn't that add up?

Its kind of a moot point in Honda Challenge. Block guards are specifically listed in the rules as an approved mod. Posting is not.



E. John Thawley III

90_EX_Civic




Offline

683 posts [94%]
PA
1-25-2008
 « Re: (thawley)« » Reply  Edit


Quote, originally posted by thawley »

Its kind of a moot point in Honda Challenge. Block guards are specifically listed in the rules as an approved mod. Posting is not.


hmm.... really, okay.



PS3 gamer tag: hmmhuh (call me 2B)

I HATE GRENADES!


ThoseDarnKids
HTGTR2 Champion



Offline

461 posts [100%]
Houston, TX
1-16-2007
 « Re: (vtecjj)« » Reply  Edit


Quote, originally posted by vtecjj »

I see what you're saying, but my guess is that the amount of water going to and through head gasket is the same with or without my block guard installed. I don't know which block guard you're talking about causing cooling issues, but I use the Golden Eagle block guard and it has adequately wide water passages-without sacraficing cylinder support. I've run the B20 with and WITHOUT the block guard and haven't seen any differences in water temps at all on the track.

The amount of water flowing through the headgasket is not the primary concern with a blockguard. The problem with a blockguard is that you are replacing engine coolant at the very top of the cylinders, where temperatures are the hottest. You wouldn't see an increase in coolant temperature because the thermostat is going to keep the temperature about the same either way, unless the coolant system was already overwhelmed. I can only imagine that cylinders are running hotter with a blockguard.

Since we're on blockguards and the B20. What is the whole purpose of a blockguard? To support the sleeve in an engine that has a less-than-ideal rod to stroke ratio, like the B20s. But, the blockguards support the very top of the cylinders, where the piston is just dwelling at TDC. There's very little thrust against the cylinder walls at that point. Most of the side thrust will occur half way down the cylinder on the intake side, after combustion, when the rod is at a high angle to the cylinder (due to the long stroke).

Here's a good read about building a B20.
http://www.theoldone.com/articles/badtothebone/
Note the 8 posts on the intake side and 4 on the exhaust side.

Also, check out their Archives for tons of info on engine building, blockguards, rod/stroke ratios, etc.



B.K.
Larsen's Biscuits | Your one stop biscuit shoppe.

thawley




Offline

1234 posts [100%]
Orange County
3-23-2004
 « Re: (ThoseDarnKids)« » Reply  Edit


Quote, originally posted by ThoseDarnKids »
Since we're on blockguards and the B20. What is the whole purpose of a blockguard? To support the sleeve in an engine that has a less-than-ideal rod to stroke ratio, like the B20s. But, the blockguards support the very top of the cylinders, where the piston is just dwelling at TDC. There's very little thrust against the cylinder walls at that point. Most of the side thrust will occur half way down the cylinder on the intake side, after combustion, when the rod is at a high angle to the cylinder (due to the long stroke).

That may be, but the open deck is going to allow more movement at the top than at the bottom. (Think of a fishing pole you're holding from the bottom: you don't need a huge movement of the hand to get a decent cast.) Don't forget that the cylinders are siamesed. If one is pushed from below, it affects the one next to it at the top.

Larry Widmer is a smart guy. And I have no doubt he's done his homework on posting vs. block guards. But I bet if he had the choice of only running with or without a block guard, he'd choose with. And the way I read the rules in HC that is our only choice...





E. John Thawley III
   First  1 2 >  Last


» Return to Road Racing/Autocross
Forum Jump
Quick Reply

Powered by ZeroForum 2.1.2b. ©2008 RelyNet, Inc.










Go